Analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia / Inah Ja Abd. Jalil

In medical ethics and law, it is highly recognized that the principle of respect for autonomy plays an integral role in decision-making. The respect, however, is not absolute and the most common explanation that the respect has been held inapplicable is due to patients’ lack of mental capacity to ma...

Full description

Saved in:

Bibliographic Details
Main Author:	Abd. Jalil, Inah Ja
Format:	Thesis
Language:	English
Published:	2021
Subjects:	Psychiatry
Online Access:	https://ir.uitm.edu.my/id/eprint/89075/1/89075.pdf
Tags:	Add Tag No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!

id	my-uitm-ir.89075
record_format	uketd_dc
spelling	my-uitm-ir.890752024-01-09T04:19:56Z Analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia / Inah Ja Abd. Jalil 2021 Abd. Jalil, Inah Ja Psychiatry In medical ethics and law, it is highly recognized that the principle of respect for autonomy plays an integral role in decision-making. The respect, however, is not absolute and the most common explanation that the respect has been held inapplicable is due to patients’ lack of mental capacity to make decisions. Assessing patients’ mental capacity is an important part of a doctor’s profession. The assessment can be taxing as it requires an intricate balance between respect for patients’ autonomy and protection to patients who lack mental capacity to make autonomous decisions. These patients are often assumed as incapable of making decisions despite not being properly assessed. However, most of these patients who are assumed to have lacked the mental capacity are actually capable of making medical decisions. This could possibly be because of the fact that there is no mental capacity law to enforce the mental capacity assessment in decision-making. Although there is a lack of reported issues or decided cases pertaining to mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia, such issues have been reported in other developed countries. The UK has legalised the concept of mental capacity through the Mental Capacity Act (MCA) 2005, which could be adopted by Malaysia as well. For this reason, this study analyses the legal perspective on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia. This study highlights the inadequacies of the existing Mental Health Act (MHA) 2001 of Malaysia and other relevant laws, regulations and policies governing medical decision-making for patients who lack mental capacity. The analysis is based on four key aspects which are (1) assessment of mental capacity, (2) consent for treatment, (3) substitute decisionmaking, (4) advance medical decisions. As a result, the MHA appear inadequate in protecting the rights of patients who lack mental capacity to make medical decisions. Finally, this study shows that it is imperative to establish legal standards of mental capacity to guide the decision-making process and to protect the rights of patients who lack mental capacity to make medical decisions. 2021 Thesis https://ir.uitm.edu.my/id/eprint/89075/ https://ir.uitm.edu.my/id/eprint/89075/1/89075.pdf text en public masters Universiti Teknologi MARA (Kampus Sg. Buloh) Faculty of Medicine Mohd Yusof, Dr. Aimi Nadia
institution	Universiti Teknologi MARA
collection	UiTM Institutional Repository
language	English
advisor	Mohd Yusof, Dr. Aimi Nadia
topic	Psychiatry
spellingShingle	Psychiatry Abd. Jalil, Inah Ja Analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia / Inah Ja Abd. Jalil
description	In medical ethics and law, it is highly recognized that the principle of respect for autonomy plays an integral role in decision-making. The respect, however, is not absolute and the most common explanation that the respect has been held inapplicable is due to patients’ lack of mental capacity to make decisions. Assessing patients’ mental capacity is an important part of a doctor’s profession. The assessment can be taxing as it requires an intricate balance between respect for patients’ autonomy and protection to patients who lack mental capacity to make autonomous decisions. These patients are often assumed as incapable of making decisions despite not being properly assessed. However, most of these patients who are assumed to have lacked the mental capacity are actually capable of making medical decisions. This could possibly be because of the fact that there is no mental capacity law to enforce the mental capacity assessment in decision-making. Although there is a lack of reported issues or decided cases pertaining to mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia, such issues have been reported in other developed countries. The UK has legalised the concept of mental capacity through the Mental Capacity Act (MCA) 2005, which could be adopted by Malaysia as well. For this reason, this study analyses the legal perspective on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia. This study highlights the inadequacies of the existing Mental Health Act (MHA) 2001 of Malaysia and other relevant laws, regulations and policies governing medical decision-making for patients who lack mental capacity. The analysis is based on four key aspects which are (1) assessment of mental capacity, (2) consent for treatment, (3) substitute decisionmaking, (4) advance medical decisions. As a result, the MHA appear inadequate in protecting the rights of patients who lack mental capacity to make medical decisions. Finally, this study shows that it is imperative to establish legal standards of mental capacity to guide the decision-making process and to protect the rights of patients who lack mental capacity to make medical decisions.
format	Thesis
qualification_level	Master's degree
author	Abd. Jalil, Inah Ja
author_facet	Abd. Jalil, Inah Ja
author_sort	Abd. Jalil, Inah Ja
title	Analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia / Inah Ja Abd. Jalil
title_short	Analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia / Inah Ja Abd. Jalil
title_full	Analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia / Inah Ja Abd. Jalil
title_fullStr	Analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia / Inah Ja Abd. Jalil
title_full_unstemmed	Analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia / Inah Ja Abd. Jalil
title_sort	analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in malaysia / inah ja abd. jalil
granting_institution	Universiti Teknologi MARA (Kampus Sg. Buloh)
granting_department	Faculty of Medicine
publishDate	2021
url	https://ir.uitm.edu.my/id/eprint/89075/1/89075.pdf
_version_	1794192197070880768

Analysing the legal perspectives on mental capacity in making medical decisions in Malaysia / Inah Ja Abd. Jalil

Similar Items