Framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis

Online Asynchronous Discussion (OAD) is a powerful way to conduct online conversation and a significant component of online learning. Unfortunately, existing Learning Management System (LMS) that generally provides online discussion cannot afford a comprehensive evaluation on the content of the tran...

Full description

Saved in:

Bibliographic Details
Main Author:	Erlin, Erlin
Format:	Thesis
Language:	English
Published:	2011
Subjects:	QA75 Electronic computers Computer science
Online Access:	http://eprints.utm.my/id/eprint/16482/1/ErlinPFC2011.pdf
Tags:	Add Tag No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!

id	my-utm-ep.16482
record_format	uketd_dc
spelling	my-utm-ep.164822019-07-08T07:15:51Z Framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis 2011-04 Erlin, Erlin QA75 Electronic computers. Computer science Online Asynchronous Discussion (OAD) is a powerful way to conduct online conversation and a significant component of online learning. Unfortunately, existing Learning Management System (LMS) that generally provides online discussion cannot afford a comprehensive evaluation on the content of the transcripts and the level of interaction among participants. Therefore, this research explores the analysis process of OAD qualitatively and quantitatively. The work focuses on Content Analysis (CA) and Social Network Analysis (SNA), two popular methods employed by educators and researchers to analyze online discussion in e-learning environment. Although these two methods are well established, the techniques remain manual. Furthermore, presently, these two methods of analysis are conducted and studied independently. Hence, this research proposes a new framework integrating CA with SNA called CASNA, which provides comprehensive information of the result, and automation of the processes. CASNA is applied and embedded in LMS (Moodle) to validate the proposed framework. This research also introduces sentence as the unit of interaction instead of message to assess the level of participation among students. In addition, in order to qualitatively analyze the online discussion, two text classifiers; the Support Vector Machine (SVM) and the Back-propagation Neural Network (BPNN) approaches are employed to categorize the sentences based on Soller’s model and the results are compared. The evaluation of these two classifiers is done based on precision, accuracy, recall and F-Measure. The result shows that SVM outperform BPNN in terms of precision and accuracy; falls behind BPNN in terms of recall and F-Measure. This research also discusses the use of network indicators of SNA. Adjacency matrix, graph theory and network analysis techniques are applied to quantitatively define the network interactions among participants. This framework takes advantage of the strength of each method and offers dynamic analysis of the textual messages. It is expected to be more informative to educators as well as researchers in measuring the quality and quantity of OAD. 2011-04 Thesis http://eprints.utm.my/id/eprint/16482/ http://eprints.utm.my/id/eprint/16482/1/ErlinPFC2011.pdf application/pdf en public http://dms.library.utm.my:8080/vital/access/manager/Repository/vital:121230 phd doctoral Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, Faculty of Computer Science and Information System Faculty of Computer Science and Information System
institution	Universiti Teknologi Malaysia
collection	UTM Institutional Repository
language	English
topic	QA75 Electronic computers Computer science
spellingShingle	QA75 Electronic computers Computer science Erlin, Erlin Framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis
description	Online Asynchronous Discussion (OAD) is a powerful way to conduct online conversation and a significant component of online learning. Unfortunately, existing Learning Management System (LMS) that generally provides online discussion cannot afford a comprehensive evaluation on the content of the transcripts and the level of interaction among participants. Therefore, this research explores the analysis process of OAD qualitatively and quantitatively. The work focuses on Content Analysis (CA) and Social Network Analysis (SNA), two popular methods employed by educators and researchers to analyze online discussion in e-learning environment. Although these two methods are well established, the techniques remain manual. Furthermore, presently, these two methods of analysis are conducted and studied independently. Hence, this research proposes a new framework integrating CA with SNA called CASNA, which provides comprehensive information of the result, and automation of the processes. CASNA is applied and embedded in LMS (Moodle) to validate the proposed framework. This research also introduces sentence as the unit of interaction instead of message to assess the level of participation among students. In addition, in order to qualitatively analyze the online discussion, two text classifiers; the Support Vector Machine (SVM) and the Back-propagation Neural Network (BPNN) approaches are employed to categorize the sentences based on Soller’s model and the results are compared. The evaluation of these two classifiers is done based on precision, accuracy, recall and F-Measure. The result shows that SVM outperform BPNN in terms of precision and accuracy; falls behind BPNN in terms of recall and F-Measure. This research also discusses the use of network indicators of SNA. Adjacency matrix, graph theory and network analysis techniques are applied to quantitatively define the network interactions among participants. This framework takes advantage of the strength of each method and offers dynamic analysis of the textual messages. It is expected to be more informative to educators as well as researchers in measuring the quality and quantity of OAD.
format	Thesis
qualification_name	Doctor of Philosophy (PhD.)
qualification_level	Doctorate
author	Erlin, Erlin
author_facet	Erlin, Erlin
author_sort	Erlin, Erlin
title	Framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis
title_short	Framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis
title_full	Framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis
title_fullStr	Framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis
title_full_unstemmed	Framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis
title_sort	framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis
granting_institution	Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, Faculty of Computer Science and Information System
granting_department	Faculty of Computer Science and Information System
publishDate	2011
url	http://eprints.utm.my/id/eprint/16482/1/ErlinPFC2011.pdf
_version_	1747815053671792640

Framework for analyzing online asynchronous discussion by integrating content analysis and social network analysis

Similar Items